
What has had the MOST IMPACT on your level of tolerance and acceptance of others?
Total Votes: 22
Some times I look back on some of my comments to other threads and see an editorial in the making. This is one of those occasions. There are two very important discussions concerning race and racism occurring on both MsCyprah's column and k-stanz's column. The articles are, respectively, "What Does Being White Mean to You" and "Race - The Pink Elephant in the Room - Can We Talk?" I want to applaud both columnists for their bravery in using NewsVine to open doors to the very heart of what is a difficult topic to discuss openly for many people. Now I ask that you read all that is to follow with an open mind. I also ask that the discussion/debate that follows remain respectful. You can express your views and disagree with others without a personal verbal assault on others and without an intentional effort to inflame others.
What I'd like to examine in this article is what our parents have taught us concerning other races, what stereotypes they may or may not have taught you about those other races, and what behavior and attitudes they patterned for you in regard to other races. I find that our parents' generation often gets a bad rap for some of the attitudes exhibited by later generations. Is this entirely fair? Were there not personal experiences of our own that may have shaped our current biases or lack of biases to more or less closely resemble that of our parents? In every life, there is some refining along the way. Many things may happen on that journey to alter the mindset our parents released us into the world with.
They say "know your enemy." For the purposes of this article, the enemy is racism and bigotry. They also say that in order to truly destroy a weed, you need to get at its root. Let's take a look at the roots of our own beliefs in regard to those who are racially, ethnically, religiously, or culturally different from ourselves. From where or under what circumstances did you form your strongest feelings, whether positive or negative, toward other races, religions, cultures, or creeds?
As you can see after reading my story, there were many influences on my attitudes. Not all of these were the direct result of learning or adopting attitudes of my parents. Here is my story, my journey, to the attitudes I have today:
Although I was only about 4 or 5 years old at the time, I have very vivid memories of Dr. King's assassination. It is my first memory that has any association with race. We lived in inner city Louisville, Ky. at the time. The rioting broke out just as my mother was driving us home after dropping my daddy off for his second shift job. High school had just let out. We were surrounded by school buses from the high school. Things were being thrown at our car, teenagers were screaming things at us that I couldn't understand and, to a 4 or 5 year old, they looked more like a bunch of very angry grown men than school kids. I remember being so afraid, I couldn't even cry, because I could sense my mama's terror.
We moved shortly after the riots. I think that was a defining moment for our future. My mom had grown up in that inner city neighborhood. We lived 2 doors away from my grandparents. She knew the names of everyone on that street. Most of the families had 3 or more generations on that street. Shortly thereafter, we were in an older suburb in South Louisville. I was getting ready to start first grade, having been one of the first "Headstart" kids in my former inner-city neighborhood. For my parents, the riots meant one thing: their children were in danger in this era of political and cultural upheaval.
I recall as a young child of 5 or 6, riding in the car with my dad in our new neighborhood. This would have been approximately late 1968. To the best of my knowledge, that was the first and last time my father heard me use the "N" word. As was considered polite and proper in those days, he sternly told me that people of color were "Negroes" and he did not want to hear that other word out of my mouth ever again. My dad was a scientist (a chemist for Celanese Coatings, later a computer engineer for Sperry Rand Univac.) He tends towards deep analysis of every subject whether it be with a 6 year old or an adult. I recall bits and pieces of his attempt to explain racial epithets using an analogy. I recall there being an alien monster in the analogy somewhere but I can't recall how he used it in the analogy. I only remember the "Purple People Eater" of song springing to mind when the monster was brought up in his explanation and he then promptly lost my attention. What I did remember clearly is my father's strong disapproval of racism and racial epithets.
Later we would move to a small Southern town called Hopkinsville on the border of Tennessee very near Fort Campbell, Ky. Although after school we were often divided by where each family could afford to live, for the most part, race was a non-issue there. Most white kids had some black kids among their closest circle of friends and vice-versa. My little "click" of closest friends was equally black and white. During our yearly Beta Club conventions, only my two black friends' parents would let them go to the "big city" so we three roomed together every year. After curfew and uninhibited by the need to hit the books on Beta weekend, we had our best debates, deepest discussions and it came as easily as talking to my little sister. It was just so easy to talk to Roz and Phyllis about race issues. I feel a great sadness that it has never been that easy since.
Near our town was a small town that was the birth place of Jefferson Davis. Every year on the anniversary of his birth, the KKK would descend upon our area in droves. Such was the case on the anniversary date somewhere in the late 1970s. One of the major intersections in town was one that we HAD to go through to get to the rest of the town. The KKK was set up at that intersection passing out literature when my dad got stopped by the light and approached. Wrong man to approach. Daddy politely declined the materials at first but then this Klansman stuck his hand in his pocket as if to imply he had a weapon pointed at my dad and told my daddy "I think you better take it." My dad is one of these people that only gets mad once a year, but when he does, look out. He told this guy "If you want to keep your damned arm, you better get this sh!t out of my face right now, you b@stard" Now my daddy is very proper with a huge vocabulary. It is extremely rare for him to use foul language. In that case, however, I was very proud of him. My parents highly approved of both Roz and Phyllis because they had wonderful values and very fine characters. I couldn't wait to tell Roz and Phyllis what daddy did at that intersection. (Rosalind H., Hannah I., and Phyllis S. from Hoptown: If you are reading this, it's Debbie and I've been trying to locate you all so e-mail me!)
It was during the years in Hopkinsville that I first started having the ability to meet people without my first reaction being a mental definition of their race. Because of my parents? Because of my friends? I just don't know.
I know that when I began nursing school and my nursing career, this ability progressed by leaps and bounds. When you work in long term care, you see your patients more often than their families do. After working with a particular patient for a period of time, (it varies from patient to patient) you get to where you worry about their case of the sniffles or a viral infection or any number of changes you've noticed long after you clocked out and went home. They become your extended family. You love them and worry about them as you would your children or your grandparents. You grieve when you lose one of them that you have become so attached to.
It is very frequent that you have to fill out forms and define race in the course of documentation and charting. After a period of time, this is the only time you give race a conscious thought. After sharing hundreds of hugs, kisses, "I love yous," being taught how to dance the old "Jelly Belly" or "The Stroll," and having confused patients tell newly admitted confused patients that "If you hurt her, you'll answer to me!" The only thing you see when you look at these people, regardless of their race, is someone you love very much and someone who makes you smile sometimes, laugh at others, and worry about them when something isn't quite right with their condition. You just don't consciously acknowledge their race except at those times you have to do it for documentation purposes. This extends to co-workers on your unit as well. The unique thing about 12 hour shifts at many facilities is that you are always working with the same crew. 4 CNAs and I worked together for 5 years. We were family to each other as well as to the patients. We were a 40/60 inter-racial crew. We took care of each other and we loved each other.
When my youngest son was just getting old enough to try to sing, 18-24 months old. We ended up in 24 hour Kroger due to the late hour and some unexpected baby necessity that had popped up. The neighborhood was deeper into inner city Cincinnati than we usually would go. It was after midnight and the store was nearly empty. I had Mason in the seat of the basket. This baby had icy blonde hair, big brown eyes and knew no strangers. Coming up one aisle of the store, Mason was singing gibberish to the top of his lungs. You couldn't understand what he was singing but the attempt at song was obvious. In the mid-way point of the aisle, we passed two black gentlemen that appeared to be in their 20s. One of these gentlemen was huge. He looked like a linebacker. As he passed us, he held up his hand for Mason to "high-five" him with his tiny little hand and as he did, the gentleman said, "Sing on, little brother, sing on!" It sounds so simplistic now, but the impact of that man's words to this little one, my baby, who he did not know, touched me deeply in such a way that it has burned that moment into my memory where it has stayed for the past 20 years. It was a whisper of brotherhood between a big man and a tiny toddler he did not know, two who outwardly were so different. It was a moment of bliss. One of those moments in which you can feel your heart swell. One of those moment you wish could happen again and again and again.
Back in about 1995, I heard a song by Western Flyer called "Cherokee Highway" for the first time. I was in a public place at the time, but the lyrics, the song was so powerful that I got a huge lump in my throat that I feared would totally block off my breath before I could get to a private spot to weep out loud. I've never had a song hit me the way that one did. I felt as if I had been punched hard in the stomach. If you are unfamiliar with the song or the lyrics, you can follow the link to read them. I wouldn't do it in a public place, though.
How about explaining your own path. What were those significant events that led to your attitudes, both positive and negative, as they stand today? When we understand what motivates us in our view of others, we come to understand ourselves. When others understand what motivates your views, you may be surprised with empathy. I'm not necessarily suggesting agreement, but a bit more tolerance and understanding of you because of understanding the journey that led you here.
Well first off, I need to point out that racism is not a big thing here in Germany, mainly due to a fairly homogeneous people in the country. I would guess the fear and dislike of foreigners comes closest to what you would consider racism in the US.
My mother who was born in 1943 became an orphan at age three and was brought up in a rather unconventional family formed by her aunt, who had an illegitimate son prior to marrying her husband. Also back in the day it was rather unusual for Protestants to marry Catholics, but her aunt was Catholic and her uncle was a Protestant. She would attend church with what soon became her dad and her brother would attend church with her mother. I guess back in those days you could really call that unusual. But I guess my mother was blessed with a somewhat unique perspective with regards to religion and life in general.
She was even more fortunate in marrying my father, who was similarly lax with observing the common stances in society. As early as the late 60ies they started to travel to then exotic places like Bulgaria and East Germany.
While my dad died while I was still very young, not even 6 years yet, my mother kind of stuck with the unconventional choices. Two of her close circle of friends were bi-racial, which is was rather rare back then. She invited the uncle of one of those friends to virtually all family and other celebrations, which of course raised many eyebrows. Hello, who would invite a 6 foot, black American, speaking Frankonian slang to family functions?!? Well my mother did. Through working and many activities she also met several homosexual people, who were just as welcome as the rest. For crying out loud this woman even invited Buddhist monks into her living room to allow them to talk about their religion.
I guess it is safe to say I had a lot of exposure to virtually all walks of life from a young age on. Naturally, as a young person the realization of how fortunate I was didn't set in until later. I really found how welcoming my mother was, when I compared her to the parents of my husband, who are typical white, middle-class Republicans and have a rather closed mind to minorities.
When I truly overcame most of my resentments for others was the time I lived as a foreigner in a different country though. I naturally adjusted and assimilated to most American things, however there were small things I would not give up and thus I could really start to appreciate what foreigners go through here in Germany. being the odd one taught me a thing or two ;-)
As of now, I guess I am the most open to all things in my family. My mother by now hesitates to allow for differences she wouldn't have minded when she was younger. It will be interesting to see how I will age with regards to that.
Honestly, I think some of it has to do with the media. Foreign youth are often portrayed as the villains, especially youth from Muslim nations. And I think to some extend that stuck, simply because we didn't have many Arabic friends, for some odd reason. Sometimes the media here functions similarly to the media in the US. For instance you have a group Turkish youth beat up an old guy it will be all over the news, headlines so to speak, if a group German youth does it, you don't hear much about it. It's a crying shame, but I think that's the way is everywhere.
I think if she actually met someone from those foreign cultures she probably wouldn't decline meeting them or anything, just the opportunity hasn't been there yet.
Thanks for posting this-- I think its good to discuss these issues.
However, in light of my experiences in numerous internet discussion forums, I do find this statement a bit strange: "I want to applaud both columnists for their bravery in using NewsVine to open doors to the very heart of what is a difficult topic to discuss openly for many people". It seems to me that, while it may be difficult to discuss for some people, I have seen it discussed quite frequently in inline forums, and Newsvine is no exception. It seems to me that it is a sensible thing to do, bringing up the issue for discussion. And bringing up controversial topics is a great way to get page views-- and votes. But somehow, I think we tend to be a little to free with the use of the term "bravery"...???? Just my two ceonts... :-)
Kyana this is from your #4
I do feel that both being in a position of being a minority on the Vine
I took this statement to mean that you believe you are a minority on the Vine. How do you know that?
But perhaps you meant it more rhetorically.
Epiphany Experiences- having to maintain order in a classroom, where fights break out easily causes me work for understanding and peace.
Glad to be here.
Nicely done, Kyana. However, I'd have to totally disagree with you in regards to Ms. CYPRAH. Every post I've seen of hers has to do with race or gender. What's up with that?
OCM-there are many fascinating sociological manifestations on NV. :0) Since we are free to write in our own style as long as we follow the COH, this is to be expected. It is challenging to discuss ideas detached from human experience, thus, personality, age, gender, experience, ethnicity, and so forth, inform our writing. We write from our deeply held beliefs, education, and skill. Perhaps a person possessing positive experience in dealing with issues such as racism, bigotry, or any kind of bias, brings that strength to the conversation here on NV. I broadly agree with your observation. Each persons slant teaches me much about myself and others.
That was a nice article, KyanaBelle.
KyanaBelle- Thanks for the post and the opportunity to reflect on our beliefs. Parent's attitudes, behaviors, and teaching greatly influence world view. But personality, shyness, talkativeness, fearlessness, also must be included. My father is very talkative, invitational and fearless of meeting all kinds of folks, so I have developed a very open attitude. My mother is shy and rather prejudiced. We emulate dad. Mom's influence is minimized. Dad's gregarious, inquisitive, and well traveled life set the tone for our home.
Financial, intellectual, physical, and spiritual security gave me a sense of strength and lack of fear of otherness. However, I understand how a person with intellectual, spiritual, and financial poverty and bad experiences could develop alot of negative attitudes. I can imagine how a scary experience like your childhood story, could influence a person's attitudes, and I have had no KKK experiences.
The inner city school where I teach has some racial tension. I set the tone for my classroom with my inclusive and affirming words, actions, and love. We have good times. These kids come with plenty of baggage from their parents prejudices.
It was a moment of bliss. One of those moments in which you can feel your heart swell. One of those moment you wish could happen again and again and again.
I believe this does happen again and again. We may not see it with the physical eye, but every moment of every day some place in the world a song is sung, a hand is touched, eyes meet, a prayer goes up, kind word go forth, more folks in the world, work toward hope than not.(your work experience is a great example)
I am comfortable with difference. Many people are not. Difference scares.
Racism and bigotry are tools of power. Everybody does not want peace and equality.
Some folks identity and survival depends on grabbing power, staying angry, persecuted, and different. We have learned to trust, some just do not want to learn and this entrenched belief is a deeply held core value.
I look forward to reading the song lyrics. Thanks for sharing your heart.
Kyana- read the lyrics I understand.;~(
sometimes when we touch the honesty's too much ... Dan Hill Newsvine is so human. Human is good. Thanks again.
Very touching article... I read through the entire thing completely en rapt.
I grew up in Northeast Washington in a rural farming community that had one "black" child in the entire school. He was, by far, one of the most popular kids in school. Although he was one of the nicer and more personable kids at school, I believe that it was more the "novelty" than anything else. I really don't give much credit to the community for tolerance, because they were very intolerant of everything else. lol
My Father was a very bigoted, angry man that used religion to back up his prejudices. His prejudice ran so far that he never openly acknowledged the fact my Mother was a German Jew. His anger and his hatreds were what, I believe, led me to my views. ( I swore at an early age to never be like him in any way).
I started openly debating my Fathers use of religion to back up his biases when I was 14 years old. Although I never changed his views I got satisfaction from standing up for what I believed in.
To this day my friends come in every color, religion and sexual preference... I define my friends by who they are, not what they are.
I've taught my children not to define people by what they are ( ie. black, white, blind, lesbian, gay...)... they are human beings with names and families... that is all the definition they need.
I think that happens quite often, that "outsiders" become somewhat of a star. Much to my daughter's dismay everyone at school knew her, because she's the only American in that school ;-)
Kyana- life's experience come, sometimes we get rigid and lose opportunities to mix and learn other times we relax into the great and beautiful diversity of humanity and give wings to all. Like riding a surf board, skiing, or dancing. Let go and learn. There are many risks, but to taste deeply of life I believe I must jump in and join the dance. Most of the time my experiences are positive, sometimes I have hit a brick wall, but all of the time I am learning, loving, living, and tasting of life. My epiphanies have come through study, travel, foods, music, art, teaching, and taking time to linger in conversation.
Our parents were mixed (father Black and mother considered 'white', though she was mixed too). There was no focus on racism or other cultures simply because we lived under colonialism and just accepted the unequal way Black people were treated. There were no Blacks in government, all managerial positions were held by Whites or people of mixed race and all the heroes and successful people in books were all White. It was quite an existence being in the majority of the population, but well nigh invisible in all respects. My adult life changed all my perspectives, assumptions and knowledge of colour and its potential consequences and I am glad of that added experience.
When we understand what motivates us in our view of others, we come to understand ourselves. When others understand what motivates your views, you may be surprised with empathy. I'm not necessarily suggesting agreement, but a bit more tolerance and understanding of you because of understanding the journey that led you here.
Amen to that. Only by understanding and appreciating our own journey can we even begin to appreciate that of others.
An excellent, thought-provoking article, KyanaBelle. Thanks for posting it.
I feel so blessed to have so many friends from so many backgrounds... I also feel blessed that I easily make friends. The most exciting part of making new friends is learning about them... their cultural differences, spiritual beliefs, personal beliefs, parenting styles.... everything. I can honestly say that my friends are the "family I've always wanted."
Kyana- take it easy glad you got to the fair pain and all It is such a beautiful time of year.
You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead. |